Deer are known to be voracious eaters, and their feeding preferences can have a significant impact on the health and survival of various plant species, including pine trees. Understanding which pine trees deer are more likely to consume can help gardeners, landscapers, and forest managers make informed decisions about their plant selections and implement effective deer management strategies.
Bosnian Pine (Pinus heldreichii ‘Leucodermis’)
Bosnian Pine, also known as Heldreich’s Pine, has a moderate nutritional value for deer. Its needles provide some protein and fiber, making them moderately palatable to deer. However, Bosnian Pine is not a preferred food source for deer, and they may only browse on its needles during late winter or early spring when other food sources are scarce.
White Pine (Pinus strobus)
White Pine needles are relatively low in nutritional value for deer, providing limited protein and fiber. Deer find White Pine needles less palatable due to their soft, blue-green color and waxy texture. As a result, deer may only occasionally browse on White Pine needles during extreme winter conditions when other food sources are depleted.
Colorado Blue Spruce (Picea pungens)
The Colorado Blue Spruce, known for its distinctive blue-green foliage, is also low in nutritional value for deer. Deer find the stiff, sharp points and blue-green color of Colorado Blue Spruce needles less palatable. Similar to White Pine, deer may occasionally browse on Colorado Blue Spruce needles during late winter or early spring when other food sources are scarce.
Deer-Proof Pine Trees
While some pine species are more susceptible to deer browsing, there are also pine trees that are considered relatively deer-resistant. Two examples of deer-proof pine trees are:
- Japanese Black Pine (Pinus thunbergiana): This species is relatively deer-resistant due to its dense, prickly foliage and conical shape, making it difficult for deer to access.
- Scotch Pine (Pinus sylvestris): Scotch Pine is also deer-resistant due to its reddish bark and 2-inch long needles, which are less preferred by deer.
Advanced Strategies for Protecting Pine Trees from Deer Damage
In addition to selecting deer-resistant pine species, there are several advanced strategies that can be employed to protect pine trees from deer damage:
- Fencing Options:
- Install 8-foot tall fencing around the tree to prevent deer from reaching the foliage.
-
Use fencing materials like wood, metal, or plastic mesh with openings no larger than 4 inches to prevent deer from passing through.
-
Repellents:
- Apply taste repellents like Bobbex or Deer Out regularly throughout the growing season to deter deer.
-
Use scent repellents like Milorganite Fertilizer or Irish Spring soap to deter deer, especially during warm weather.
-
Habitat Modification Techniques:
- Plant deer-resistant species around the perimeter of the area to divert deer attention away from the pine trees.
- Create a deer-deterring landscape by incorporating plants with strong scents, thorns, or bitter tastes.
Quantitative Data on Deer Feeding Habits and Preferences
According to research, deer typically spend 2-4 minutes feeding on a single tree, with an average of 10-15 minutes spent feeding per day. Additionally, deer have been observed to prefer deciduous trees like Crabapples, Lindens, and Japanese Maples over evergreen trees like pines and spruces.
Relevant Studies and Observations
A study by Rosedale Nurseries found that deer tend to avoid evergreen trees like White Pines and Norway Spruces, preferring deciduous trees instead. Furthermore, it has been observed that deer are creatures of habit and will return to the same feeding areas if not deterred, making consistent protection measures essential.
Reference:
– Rosedale Nurseries. (2023). Plants Usually Not Damaged By Deer. Retrieved from https://rosedalenurseries.com/plants-usually-not-damaged-by-deer/
– Colorado State Forest Service. (n.d.). Colorado’s Major Tree Species. Retrieved from https://csfs.colostate.edu/colorado-trees/colorados-major-tree-species/
– Bend Pine Nursery. (n.d.). Our Favorite Evergreen Trees. Retrieved from https://bendpinenursery.com/our-favorite-evergreen-trees/